Operant learning, the process of trial and error to observe outcomes in various situations, is a fundamental method through which dogs acquire knowledge. Modern dog training heavily relies on this approach, with behaviors either increasing or decreasing based on the consequences they incur. It is crucial for effective and fair training to comprehend what is known as the Four Consequences of Behavior. Let's delve into each of them and explore their functions.

 

R+ (Positive Reinforcement)

Positive reinforcement (R+) involves adding something desirable to the dog's environment, rewarding the behavior and increasing the likelihood of its recurrence. For example, when a dog sits on command and receives a reward, it associates the action with a positive outcome. Positive reinforcement plays a central role in training, aiming to make desired behaviors more frequent.

 

P- (Negative Punishment)

Negative punishment (P-) entails the removal of something desirable, resulting in a decrease in the behavior. For instance, if a puppy bites its owner's hands and the owner turns away, hides their hands, or leaves the puppy and walks away from play, the removal of attention acts as negative punishment. Similarly, withholding play or ending a walk when the dog pulls on the leash is an example. Negative punishment is an effective way to reduce unwanted behaviors.

 

P+ (Positive Punishment)

Positive punishment (P+) involves adding something undesirable to decrease a behavior, aiming to make the dog want to avoid the added consequence. Examples include a dog putting its paw on a hot surface, the owner pulling the leash attached to a prong collar when the dog barks on a walk, or spraying water on a dog that barks at a cat. Positive punishment, while used, needs to be applied carefully to avoid adverse effects on the dog's well-being.

 

R- (Negative Reinforcement)

Negative reinforcement (R-) is the removal of something aversive when the desired behavior occurs, making the behavior more likely to happen again. An example is a dog's discomfort easing when it stops pulling on the leash. While negative reinforcement is part of training, it requires caution to ensure the dog's welfare and avoid unnecessary discomfort.

Approaching these terms without attaching ethical judgments is essential, as they simply describe whether something is added or removed to influence behavior. The terms positive and negative don't imply moral value. Positive reinforcement doesn't automatically mean being kind to the dog, as positive punishment could involve harsh actions. Similarly, negative reinforcement, despite its name, doesn't necessarily imply cruelty; it involves removing something aversive to reinforce a behavior.

​

Understanding these consequences is vital for effective communication with dogs, as the choice of training methods significantly influences the dog's well-being and the quality of the relationship between the dog and its owner.

 

Why R+ Training?

My journey began when I acquired my first horse. While I had trained dogs for many years, I had previously used a mix of various methods, as many others do. When I took responsibility for a horse, I gained insights that led me to eliminate admonishments and other indefensible methods from my life. Training dogs should be enjoyable for both the owner and the dog, promoting their well-being. Positive punishment, for instance, is not only ethically questionable but also counterproductive for building a strong bond and a well-balanced, happy dog.

Avoiding negative reinforcement (R-) is also a choice grounded in ethical principles. The use of aversive stimuli contradicts the goal of training without resorting to discomfort, threats, or violence. The last resort, if necessary, is negative punishment (P-) – removing something desirable. However, even this is minimized to provide a more positive and effective training experience.

​

In summary, the foundation of R+ Dog Training lies in ethical considerations, aiming for a training approach that is both kind and effective. The emphasis on positive reinforcement not only prioritizes the dog's well-being but also facilitates clearer communication and a more harmonious relationship between the dog and its owner.

 

Beyond the Four Consequences: Extinction

In addition to the four consequences, the concept of extinction is crucial in dog training. Extinction involves eliminating the reward for a previously reinforced behavior, causing the behavior to decrease. This concept is prevalent in clicker training, where desired behaviors are reinforced (R+), and undesired behaviors are ignored (extinction).

For example, if a dog begs at the table and no longer receives food, the behavior of begging is likely to diminish. Similarly, if a dog comes when called multiple times without a rewarding experience, the behavior of coming may decrease. Understanding extinction helps in focusing on rewarding desirable behaviors and, at the same time, ignoring undesirable ones.

​

In conclusion, when training or interacting with a dog, it is essential to remember that dogs always act in a way that benefits them. This provides a fantastic opportunity to teach them precisely what we desire. By finding the right motivation and rewarding them appropriately, we can guide dogs toward behaviors that enhance their well-being and strengthen their bond with their human companions. R+ Dog Training emphasizes positive reinforcement, creating a positive and effective training experience that is ethical and enjoyable for dogs and their owners.